Search

GDPR Compliance

We use cookies to ensure you get the best experience on our website. By continuing to use our site, you accept our use of cookies, Privacy Policy, and Terms of Service.

FA Cup to keep hated rule next season despite pleas by Gary Lineker and Alan Shearer to change it after Man Utd clash

Published on April 12, 2025 at 11:53 AM

FA CUP fixtures next season will include extra time – despite calls for them to follow the Carabao Cup's suit.

The EFL scrapped extra time in the in 2018, with all fixtures – barring the final – being decided by a penalty shootout in the event of a stalemate.

Silhouette of Nottingham Forest fan holding a replica FA Cup trophy in a stadium.
FA Cup chiefs have decided against scrapping extra-time for next season
Silhouette of Nottingham Forest fan holding a foil FA Cup replica.
They have been facing calls to get rid of it to give lower league teams chances of victory

But FA chiefs, according to the Times, aren't planning to follow suit.

That's despite their recent scrapping of replays, which used to be huge money-spinners for lower league clubs.

The decision to axe replays was widely condemned, with many believing it was made to cater to Premier League clubs' fixture schedules.

Lower league sides are at a clear disadvantage in terms of squad depth and fitness levels when games go to extra time.

That fact wasn't more apparent when non-League Tamworth Town took the full 90 minutes in their third-round tie in January.

The Lambs did extraordinarily well to hold Spurs to a 0-0 draw but ended up conceding three goals in extra-time against the much fitter Premier League side.

Extra time that day cruelly denied Tamworth a huge payday at the Tottenham Hotspur Stadium.

The money generated from a replay would've been invaluable to The Lambs.

Pedro Porro of Tottenham Hotspur shoots at goal during a soccer match.
Extra time cruelly denied Tamworth Town a replay against Tottenham

Getting rid of extra time and going straight to penalties would somewhat level the playing field between lower league clubs and teams in the top-flight.

Additionally, it would go some way to helping tackle the issue of player fatigue.

Several high-profile figures are keen on scrapping extra time in Cup matches, including .

Speaking on The Rest is Football podcast, he said: “We've argued many times, just get rid of extra time. Just go to penalties. It makes so much sense.

“Particularly with the amount of football teams are playing now, the amount of injuries we're getting. Just play 90 minutes, then settle it on penalties.

“Because once it goes to extra time, the vast majority of us are thinking, particularly when it's as bad as it was last night [Man Utd vs Fulham], you're just thinking, ‘Come on, penalty shootout, a bit of excitement.'”

Co-host was in full agreement, saying: “Straight to penalties, I'm all for that.”

Prev Article

Shock moment two mums brawl & pull each other’s hair after row between their kids – before schoolboy had to break it up

Next Article

Louis Tomlinson parties at Coachella as Zara McDermott shops in Beverly Hills days after confirming romance

Related to this topic:

Comments (0):

Be the first to write a comment.

Post Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *