Search

Newsletter image

Subscribe to the Newsletter

Join 10k+ people to get notified about new posts, news and tips.

Do not worry we don't spam!

GDPR Compliance

We use cookies to ensure you get the best experience on our website. By continuing to use our site, you accept our use of cookies, Privacy Policy, and Terms of Service.

Man Utd ratings: Joshua Zirkzee bright before injury woe but how did Andre Onana’s replacement do?

Published on April 13, 2025 at 05:41 PM

MANCHESTER UNITED'S worst ever Premier League season was confirmed with a 4-1 defeat to Newcastle.

The Red Devils are now guaranteed to finish on less than 56 points, which is their lowest ever Prem total, even if they win all of their last six games.

Altay Bayindir failed to make the most of his rare chance between the sticks
Manchester United's Joshua Zirkzee being helped off the pitch by medical staff.
Joshua Zirkzee impressed before going off injured

It was another dark day that reflects a poor campaign for United as Newcastle carved them open with ease in the second-half.

Sandro Tonali's volley, a double by Harvey Barnes and a Bruno Guimaraes finish cancelled out Alejandro Garnacho's goal.

Here is how ‘s Gary Stonehouse rated the United performances.

ALTAY BAYINDIR – 4

All eyes were on the Turkish goalie as he replaced the dropped Andre Onana.

He didn’t put a foot wrong in the early stages of his Premier League debut and made a superb save to deny Alexander Isak in the first half.

But that all went to pot as the Red Devils began to crumble, and he gift-wrapped one the Magpies the fourth when chipping straight to Joelinton.

Set the nerves jangling a few more times to leave the manager with one big question – is it time for Tom Heaton to come in?

Pass map of Altay Bayindir v Newcastle: 27 completed passes, 30 incomplete passes.

NOUSSAIR MAZRAOUI – 4

Looked to be doing alright in the opening period as he often teamed up with Diogo Dalot to try keep out Harvey Barnes

Though, like his team-mates, absolutely went to pieces once Newcastle stepped it up.

His mistake for the third goal summed up his poor display.

VICTOR LINDELOF – 5

Marshalled the defence well as the centre of the three during the first period.

But the Swede must have felt like the boy with his finger in the dike next to Yoro and Mazraoui.

Looked a man with the world on his shoulders once he got the armband late on and will no doubt have been counting down the seconds until full time.

Illustration of Victor Lindelof's match statistics against Newcastle, including minutes played, passes, tackles, fouls conceded, and duels won/lost, shown on a heatmap of his activity on the field.

LENY YORO – 4

Not the finest display from the young Frenchmen, who was booked for tussling before a corner in the opening period.

Huge question marks over him positionally for Newcastle’s first two goals.

And then a sloppy pass out that almost led to another goal midway through the second period typified this abject performance.

Pass map of Leny Yoro v Newcastle: 62 completed passes, 6 incomplete passes.

DIOGO DALOT – 5

Could have been stronger in a few first half challenges but offered a lot of threat in the United attacks.

His pace led to the equaliser but once couldn’t make any more of an impact in the second period.

And he will be upset that he failed to shut out the threat of two-goal Barnes.

MANUEL UGARTE – 5

Was unfortunate to go into the book early doors for what looked to be a great tackle on Tino Livramento and that meant he had to play the rest of the game on a tightrope.

It was his sloppy play that gave the ball away for Newcastle’s opener but he made up for that by outpowering Joelinton to create the equaliser.

But he was one of those that failed to step up and protect the defence once the floodgates started to open.

Manuel Ugarte vs Newcastle: 90 mins played, 44 passes, 2 tackles, 5 duels lost, 2 shots, 10 duels won; heatmap of his activity on the pitch.

CHRISTIAN ERIKSEN – 5

The Dane did constantly want the ball but did very little with it.

Outpowered, outworked and well off the pace once the going got tough.

The magic appears to be waning.

Pass map of Christian Eriksen's passes against Newcastle: 42 complete, 5 incomplete.

HARRY AMASS – 5

The 18-year-old was another making his first Premier League start and struggled with the physicality at times.

Struggled to make much of an impact going up against Jacob Murphy in attack.

And he was caught a yard off it in the build-up to Newcastle’s second before he was taken off.

Harry Amass vs Newcastle match stats: minutes played, passes, dribbles, crosses, duels won, fouls conceded, and heatmap.

BRUNO FERNANDES – 5

Intelligent performance during the first 45 minutes from the United captain.

But as his defence caved in to hand Newcastle the win, their leader was nowhere to be seen.

There was only one Bruno left smiling today – and they were wearing Black and White.

Bruno Fernandes vs Newcastle match statistics: minutes played, passes, shots, dispossessed, duels won, and duels lost, shown on a heatmap of his activity on the field.

ALEJANDRO GARNACHO – 6

His pace was a constant thorn and danger to the Newcastle defence.

And he showed great composure with a fine finish to level.

Though a sloppy pullback on a rare counter after the break was his last piece of action.

JOSHUA ZIRKZEE – 7

The Dutch forward recovered from a sloppy pass early on to produce another encouraging display.

Came close to an opener after neat play with Bruno Fernandes and battled well with Toon’s big boys Dan Burn and Fabian Schar.

Unfortunately, just as it looked like the 23-year-old’s form was building up, his season could be in threat now as he was forced off with a hamstring injury.

Joshua Zirkee vs Newcastle match statistics: minutes played, shots, duels won, passes, touches, and fouls.

SUBS:

MASON MOUNT (on for Garnacho 55 mins) – 5

Struggled to make any impact.

Like those before him, he found the Toon midfield was too hungry, physical and just simply wanted it more.

RASMUS HOJLUND (on for Zirkzee 55 mins) – 4

Tried to get involved physically with Schar and Burn but had zero luck.

Offered nothing as his side rolled over and died.

PATRICK DORGU (on for Amass 55 mins) – 5

Couple of nice touches but nothing of note. Not many will remember his fleeting out this afternoon.

LUKE SHAW (on for Mazraoui 77 mins) – 5

The only positive for him was minutes in the tank.

Came on at centre-half next to Lindelof for the closing stages and fortunately helped to not concede any more.

KOBBIE MAINOO (on for Fernandes 81 mins) – N/A

Prev Article

Abia Judiciary Panel investigates alleged demolition of school building for NALDA project

Next Article

Nigeria does not deserve leader like Tinubu – Atiku on US court order to FBI

Related to this topic:

Comments (0):

Be the first to write a comment.

Post Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *