Search

Newsletter image

Subscribe to the Newsletter

Join 10k+ people to get notified about new posts, news and tips.

Do not worry we don't spam!

GDPR Compliance

We use cookies to ensure you get the best experience on our website. By continuing to use our site, you accept our use of cookies, Privacy Policy, and Terms of Service.

Why Ruben Amorim’s Man Utd system is broken and what they need to do with Alejandro Garnacho

Published on April 07, 2025 at 07:44 PM

THE Manchester Derby didn't live up to its usual hype on Sunday as Man Utd and Man City played our a goalless bore draw.

Despite excitement over what could have been a feisty clash, as it has been over the years, fans found themselves struggling to stay awake during

Jeremy Doku of Manchester City challenges Bruno Fernandes of Manchester United during a Premier League match.
Manchester United and Man City played out a snooze-fest draw on Sunday

‘s United side failed to take advantage of their underachieving neighbours with issues all over the pitch.

In the latest episode of SunSport'sTactics Exposed, our expertDEAN SCOGGINS reveals what is broken about the Man Utd system.

GARNACHO DRIVING ME AMAD

You can't help but think what – and possibly even – would be doing in ‘s role in this Man Utd team.

Unselfish runs are so important in football these days and opening up passing lanes too, but Garnacho does the opposite.

Just 25 seconds in to the game Garnacho had a fantastic opportunity to tee up Bruno Fernandes with a simple pass, but chose not to play the ball.

Garnacho's run-direction is often the wrong way. It's not that he always goes left or always goes right, it's that he doesn't seem to have the awareness of what's around him to make the right run.

In ‘s 3-4-2-1 shape, Garnacho should be making runs to occupy defenders or make himself an option whenever gets the ball.

Instead, Garncho and seem to always make runs into the same central positions.

It might be time to start to question whether the Argentine is understanding what is being asked of him by the new manager.


Illustration of a soccer play showing Garnacho passing to Fernandes.

Soccer players on a field with a highlighted area showing Garnacho's position.

Soccer game screenshot showing players Dorgú and Garnacho.

OPEN THE DORGU

Dorgu worked really hard and he did fantastically well to get up and down the pitch to try and implement Amorim's system.

Amorim's system means that overloading one side of the pitch can often leave a wing-back wide open on the other flank – a position Dorgu found himself in multiple times.

However, his barnstorming runs were either not being spotted quick enough by his midfield teammates or Garnacho was getting in his way in the wide areas.

United need to release Dorgu earlier so he can be the one to put the crosses in the box.

Amorim's side didn't take advantage of ‘s narrow system.

Had they defended narrow and then spread the ball wide when they attacked, United could have had more joy against their neighbours.

Patrick Dorgu's heatmap from Manchester United vs. Manchester City match.

Illustration of Patrick Dorgu's 57 touches in a Man United vs Man City match.

Soccer game screenshot showing a play.

Illustration of a soccer play showing a pass from Dorgu to Garnacho.

Illustration of a soccer team lineup.

TRUST ISSUES

Man Utd players don't seem to be trusting the players behind them, causing trust issues that are hampering their performances.

The attackers leading the press seem to not trust the midfielders behind them to do their job when it comes to marking the opposition.

That makes them drop back and try to help out, subsequently seeing the midfielders drop back to mark the deeper men and meaning United's back three are left marking nobody and very little pressure being put on the ball.

Being pushed so far back means that when United win the ball back they aren't high enough up the pitch and they are no longer 1v1 with their opposite numbers.

It also stops United from being able to transition quick enough from defence into attack.

The system doesn't seem to be an issue, it could be more of a personnel problem.

Illustration of Manchester United and Manchester City soccer team formations.

Illustration of Manchester United and Manchester City football team formations.

Illustration of Manchester United and Manchester City soccer team formations.
When they do get the ball back they are too deep and outnumbered by the Man City defence

BRUNO… IT MAKES SENSE

was really good against City, he was at the heart of every good move that United had.

By playing him as one of the attacking three, you have his game intelligence to help them create opportunities and utilise the system.

At the moment he doesn't look like he wants to pass to Rasmus Hojlund and doesn't have the runs off the ball from elsewhere to feed the passes.

There were multiple occasions where Fernandes had the ball in central areas and everyone else was narrow too.

If players move into wide areas then Fernandes could definitely be the key to unlocking more and finding the right passes.

Bruno Fernandes was the best player on the pitch for Man Utd on Sunday
Fernandes has been Man Utd's best player this season

STRIKER LIGHT

Both Manchester clubs were light up top during the derby, but Man City had an excuse with their superstar striker missing through injury.

Meanwhile United had both Rasmus Hojlund and available to them and still didn't manage to find the back of the net.

Hojlund has scored just one goal in his last 24 games in all competitions, while Zirkzee only has a marginally better record with two goals in his last 22 appearances for United.

Hojlund hasn't been getting the service that he should be, given the ssues that have already been highlighted, but his average position is baffling.

The striker's average position at half-time was deeper than ‘s.

The Dane doesn't push the defender back as much as he should and it seems like he has a lack of confidence when it comes to beating a defender 1v1.

Zirkzee offered much more in terms of stretching the City defence, but he just isn't fast enough to make his runs effective.

Soccer game screenshot showing players on the field; "Højlund" is highlighted.
Rasmus Hojlund was so deep throughout the game
Illustration of Rasmus Højlund's Premier League 2024-25 stats.
It has been a disappointing campaign for Hojlund
Prev Article

Watch the moment CBB’s Danny Beard broke down in tears after failed BGT audition as Simon Cowell brands him ‘weird’

Next Article

I’m a single mum & gave my kitchen a pink zebra transformation with The Range bargains – some hate it but I’m made up

Related to this topic:

Comments (0):

Be the first to write a comment.

Post Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *